WATER
5The Legendary Fisherman
Archetype:
Umi
ATK:
1850
DEF:
1600
View:
4218
While "Umi" is on the field, this card is unaffected by Spell effects and cannot be targeted for attacks, but does not prevent your opponent from attacking you directly.
The Legendary Fisherman — Power Evaluation
Final Score: 43 ± 6 · Confidence: Medium
- Intrinsic: 41.8 · Deck: 43.1 · Meta: provisional
- Primary role: Material body · Secondary: Utility
Why it scores here
The Legendary Fisherman converts into a conditional protective body and, more practically, a Level 5 WATER Warrior body that is co-played 65.8% of the time with The Legendary Fisherman III across 76 recent decks. It reliably offers nothing else: there are zero combo appearances in the sample, no search route is supplied, and its text grants no disruption, card advantage, or recursion. Its 1850 ATK and 1600 DEF earned no points here — a body this size would only matter if it converted efficiently, and the supplied evidence shows it does not. The score reflects an Umi-locked support body that is cheap to slot but dependent on a field Spell to function at all.
Axis scores
| Axis | Score | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Accessibility | 45 | Level 5 WATER Warrior with no dedicated searcher in the supplied evidence that must usually be drawn, yet it appears in 76 recent decks at an average of 1.41 copies (observed). |
| Combo & Conversion | 22 | Zero combo appearances in the sample, so conversion is text-only: one Level 5 body that needs a tribute (or a Level-reducing field) before it does anything (inferred). |
| Resource Economy | 25 | The text grants no search, draw, or GY recursion, so playing it is a flat body investment whose only return is conditional protection (verified). |
| Effect & Interaction | 15 | It provides no disruption, negation, or removal of any kind — the clause is purely defensive and never interacts with the opponent's plays (verified). |
| Material Utility | 45 | A Level 5 WATER Warrior that still serves as tribute/fusion material even when its effect is blanked or Umi is absent, reflected in 65.8% co-decking with The Legendary Fisherman III (observed). |
| Resilience & Flexibility | 40 | While Umi is on the field it is unaffected by Spell effects and cannot be targeted for attacks, but the protection is one-sided and the opponent may still attack directly (verified). |
| Deck-Building Efficiency | 42 | It is a single low-cost slot — 56 of 76 decks run exactly 1 copy and Umi Control shows 100% inclusion at 1 — but it is close to dead without Umi on the field (observed). |
Calculation
Weight profile: 0.7 Material body + 0.3 Utility. Intrinsic ≈ 41.8, Deck ≈ 43.1, Meta = provisional. Modifiers: none. Final formula: 0.40*Intrinsic + 0.60*Deck
Strengths
- Cheap one-slot inclusion: 76 recent decks run it at an average of 1.41 copies
- Reliable partner for The Legendary Fisherman III (65.8% co-decking) as a Level 5 WATER Warrior body
- Under Umi it is unaffected by Spell effects and cannot be targeted for attacks, which blunts targeted removal and attack-based answers
- Works inside an established Umi shell alongside Sea Stealth Attack, Sea Stealth II and The Legendary Fisherman II
- Still functions as tribute/fusion material when its effect is negated or Umi is absent
Weaknesses
- The entire effect is conditional on Umi being face-up on the field; without it the card is a blank Level 5 body
- No disruption, negation, or removal — it never interacts with the opponent's plays
- No search, draw, or recursion in the supplied evidence, so it is a flat body investment
- 1850 ATK is low for a Level 5 that normally requires a tribute
- The attack protection does not stop direct attacks, which the opponent can simply take
Counters / choke points
- Removing Umi (e.g. backrow removal aimed at the field Spell) switches off both the Spell immunity and the attack-targeting protection
- Non-targeting removal bypasses the 'cannot be targeted for attacks' clause entirely
- Monster-effect and Trap-based removal are unaffected by the 'unaffected by Spell effects' clause
- Direct attacks ignore the card completely since it cannot be attacked but does not prevent direct attacks
Best use
Umi-locked protective Level 5 body / material for the Legendary Fisherman line. Decks: Umi Control, Umi, Phantasm Spiral. Suggested copies: 1.
Evidence & gaps
- Verified: Card text: while 'Umi' is on the field, this card is unaffected by Spell effects and cannot be targeted for attacks, but does not prevent the opponent from attacking directly; Card identity: Level 5 WATER Warrior, 1850 ATK / 1600 DEF, archetype Umi, legal in TCG/OCG/Master Duel/Duel Links; The card has no search, draw, removal, negation or recursion clause in its text
- Observed: 76 recent decks run it, all in the main deck, at an average of 1.41 copies (56 decks run exactly 1); Co-deck rates: The Legendary Fisherman III 65.8%, Sea Stealth Attack 59.2%, Sea Stealth II 57.9%, The Legendary Fisherman II 56.6%, Kairyu-Shin's Dark Reef 56.6%; 31 distinct archetypes appear; top homes are Umi (19.7%), Umi Control (11.8%), Phantasm Spiral (7.9%) and Fish (7.9%); Usage statistics: Umi Control shows 100% inclusion at 1 typical copy; combo data reports 0 combo appearances, 0% as starter/material/payoff, and no recorded power index
- Inferred: Its practical role is a material/body piece for the Legendary Fisherman line rather than a standalone threat, given the 65.8% co-decking with The Legendary Fisherman III; The protective clause is heavily conditional — it does nothing until Umi is face-up, so the card's floor is a plain Level 5 tribute body; Under a Level-reducing WATER field such as A Legendary Ocean (co-decked in 47.4% of its decks) it would become summonable without tribute, improving its floor
- Data gaps: no combos supplied — combo conversion is text-only inference no guides supplied no banlist token — assumed 3 copies (unlimited) no per-format split of the deck sample despite legality in four formats no explicit evidence of how the card is used in the Legendary Fisherman III line (material vs. payoff)






